191 Comments
User's avatar
Lovingly Known As Midge's avatar

I’m thinking comments here are missing the point of Austen. She is not a romance writer, she writes comedies of manners. The manners very much of her time and place. In Pride and Prejudice Elizabeth speaks about class from a very modern feminist perspective.

Expand full comment
Kailani B.'s avatar

I think the reason a lot of people would call Austen a romance author is because that’s why they’re reading her books. Sure, you can dissect the class issues, which are very strange from an American’s perspective. But I doubt people re-read the books because they just loooove talking about social hierarchy. They want romance and she wrote great romances.

Expand full comment
Lovingly Known As Midge's avatar

She did write great romances. I did not mean to suggest her books are about class but they more than just a romance. I was responding to the comments about her books being about women just waiting around to be saved by a man. That they are not or Mrs Bennett would not be a comical character

Expand full comment
Michelle's avatar

Austen was not a romance writer. Unfortunately, the movies of her books used that angle to hook people in.

Expand full comment
Annette Gordon's avatar

With you one hundred percent.

And though the manners are very time & place - the snobbery & meanness her heroines encounter is still with us.

I love Austen. She has much to say about life & how hard it is.

And she was very subversive & an advocate for women.

Expand full comment
Catherine's avatar

For Austen, I will always recommend Northanger Abbey — it’s so underrated but so so good, and has something that’s a bit different from the others.

I felt a lot of the same way about the Evelyn Hardcastle, but I think I got turned off it just less than 2/3 of the way through

Expand full comment
Kailani B.'s avatar

I did read Northanger Abbey and it was fine. But I have to admit I preferred the 2007 movie. Maybe it’s because I saw it before reading the book.

Expand full comment
Catherine's avatar

Ooh I had no idea there was a movie! I’ll have to check that out

Expand full comment
Kailani B.'s avatar

The actor who plays Tilney is great!

Expand full comment
With the Fairies's avatar

Yes it's unlike the rest of her work. A parody of the Gothic genre.

Expand full comment
Wolf's avatar

I really liked 11/22/63 by King. It's LONG, but the ending has stuck with me more than any other book I've read.

Expand full comment
Kailani B.'s avatar

I did try watching the series they made several years ago but I never finished it. I’m sure the book is much better though; I’ll add it to my list.

Expand full comment
Anna Fox-Rothman's avatar

I love that book

Expand full comment
Jim Perry's avatar

I was going to suggest A Christmas Carol for Dickens, but it’s the only thing of his I’ve ever read. Just the right length for his style, though.

Not sure what your bag is, but if you are mildly interested in Epic Fantasy, Larry Correia’s Son of the Black Sword is better than any Martin, Jordan or Sanderson you might otherwise pick up.

Expand full comment
Kailani B.'s avatar

I recently read A Christmas Carol and really liked it. Here’s my review if you’re interested:

https://damselinthelibrary.substack.com/p/a-christmas-carol-made-me-appreciate

I do enjoy fantasy books and that Correia book has been recommended to me before. It’s on my list.

Expand full comment
Elicia Johnson's avatar

I love your honesty! I hear what you're saying about Gaiman.

As far as Austen goes, I like Emma much better than the ever-popular P&P. Lady Susan is a delightful treat. I applaud you for not being a lemming about her, though. In that literary vein, Elizabeth Gaskell's North & South is so much better! It has the same polite enemies-to-lovers trope, but a much richer story.

Expand full comment
Kailani B.'s avatar

What’s the point of sharing a book-ish opinion if it isn’t honest? As for North and South, I LOVE it!! I re-read it last year and I did a review: https://damselinthelibrary.substack.com/p/re-reading-north-and-south-by-elizabeth

and I’m going to be talking about the adaptation next month.

Expand full comment
Allison's avatar

The Gunslinger, was written when King was 19. And it reads like a 19 year old wrote it. I highly recommend the rest of the Dark Tower books. They are much, much better. So much so that when I suggest this series I always say read the Gunslinger. You won't like it, it's a meh book but read The Drawing of the Three and decide from there. Also, I enjoyed The Eyes of the Dragon and was completely charmed by Fairy Tale. Or perhaps try his short stories. I'm very fond of a short story...its like a charcuterie board of literature. Also, the Shining and Dr. Sleep. One written by King the addict and one written by King when sober. But I'm a longtime King fan, I think his middle works are the best.

Expand full comment
Kailani B.'s avatar

Thanks for your recommendations! I will continue with the Dark Tower series.

Expand full comment
Elizabeth M. Johnson (she/her)'s avatar

I was hoping someone would mention The Eyes of The Dragon! Total King sleeper that most people don’t know about. But I think it’s one of his best.

Expand full comment
Allison's avatar

Fairy Tale recaptured that feeling when I read Eyes of the Dragon.

Expand full comment
Elizabeth M. Johnson (she/her)'s avatar

I’d hoped for that feeling but using the present day as setting distracted me from that. Glad it worked for you though!

Expand full comment
Nissa Harlow's avatar

I DNF'd the second book in the Throne of Glass series. This girl was supposed to be the best assassin... and I'd yet to see her kill anyone. (Sort of like how that travel blogger was never shown travel blogging, I guess.)

The only novel of Stephen King's that I've read is Carrie. I enjoyed it, but it didn't make me want to run out and read all his other stuff. One I am kind of intrigued with is Misery... though I don't know if that's the best choice for an author!

Expand full comment
Kailani B.'s avatar

Haha! A great assassin indeed. I hate it when an author hypes up a character’s skills and we never see any proof.

I think I might try some more King this year, maybe around Halloween. Misery does sound like a risky choice though!

Expand full comment
outlet's avatar

I read a lot of King as a teen and then reread a bunch of them in my late 20's and thought most of them were actually pretty bad books the second time around. Misery is one of the few that held up and is still one of my favorite modern fiction books. Plus the movie is good too.

Expand full comment
Geoff Mantooth's avatar

King’s Misery is a good one, even for authors to prepare us for rabid fans. 😅 I also like his Holly, a thriller filled with a cast of interesting characters, and well-told in terms of pacing, description, conflict, not to mention a pair of truly evil ordinary people.

Expand full comment
David Perlmutter's avatar

Try Dickens' first book, "The Pickwick Papers". He knew how to do comedy, at least.

Expand full comment
Amelia M's avatar

Not counting A Christmas Carol, Pickwick Papers is the only Dickens I’ve read. I don’t even remember getting through high school assignments, but I happened upon PP when still in school, and I really loved it. I read a lot of humor at the time (Thurber, Mr. Blandings Build His Dream House, more) and for me it ranked with all of them. [PS Mr. B was made into a movie successfully I think; the story is a raft of things that go wrong when building your suburban dream, from the time when Connecticut was being built up. NB there is a scene with a black maid that troubles people today for stereotype, but for me at the time it was okay because she saves the day for him. Standards have changed so I don’t disagree with anyone who rejects it. But it’s a thread among many in the plot.]

Expand full comment
Kailani B.'s avatar

I was thinking about trying Oliver Twist or Great Expectations, but a comedy sounds like a better choice. Thanks for the recommendation!

Expand full comment
Laura's avatar

Oliver Twist was my first attempt at Dickens, aside from a free course on Christmas Carol, and it’s been sitting unfinished on the side table for months. I can see the social commentary he was aiming for, but I really haven’t been able to get invested.

Expand full comment
Kailani B.'s avatar

Dickens is a divisive author, but I very much enjoyed A Christmas Carol, and I did a review for it too:

https://damselinthelibrary.substack.com/p/a-christmas-carol-made-me-appreciate

Expand full comment
Eric Brown's avatar

I read A Man Called Ove and it was ok, but My Grandmother Asked Me to Tell You She's Sorry really hit me in the gut. Amazing stuff.

Expand full comment
M.S. Olney's avatar

I always think the most underated author was James Herbert. I have enjoyed every single one of his novels. Some are more action packed than others whilst some are genuinely scary and I never get scared by movies or books usually.

Expand full comment
Kailani B.'s avatar

I’ve never heard of him. Any particular recommendation on where to start?

Expand full comment
Jason Duck's avatar

The Rats, The Fog and 48.

Expand full comment
Dustin Hopkins's avatar

The thing you have to remember about Dickens is that although he wasn’t paid by the word….his stuff was published serially. That is going to lend itself to a certain style of writing and pacing.

Expand full comment
The Crazy Cat Lady Writes's avatar

King jumped the shark years ago. However, his writing has been such a huge influence on mine, that I've just become more selective in newer stuff of his I read. Also he's been cranking out books so fast, it's hard to keep up.

As for Gaimen....ugh. My husband pestered me for YEARS that I had to read Sandman. When I finally caved, it was like what took me so long. And the series (ok, season 1 is all that's out) is OMG AMAZEBALLS. I've read all of his stuff, but given his behavior, I'm kinda done.

Another big disappointment for me was Marion Zimmer Bradley's The Mists of Avalon. I've always had a passing interest in the whole King Arthur thing and I loved this book because it tells the story from a women's point of view. However.....a lot of not nice things came out about her (child abuse) and I can't bring myself to re read the book like I used to.

Expand full comment
Moloko's avatar

Funnily enough I had the same exact experience with King, dropping the Shining. That was until I was gifted “On Writing”. I didn’t expect his memoir to hit so right, but I guess reading something that pertains very clearly to me makes sense to have connected. It was so conversational and doesn’t linger on anything. He even tells his own personal story of how he believes his upbringing brought him to writing. Shortly after that I read Misery and went on a Stephen King binge. Can’t recommend that one enough, though it’s likely not for everyone.

Expand full comment
Jason Duck's avatar

I love King but agree he can be hit and miss. But the guy is such a perlific writer there's bound to be some misfires among the greatness. My favourites are, The Stand, It, Firestarter, Misery and Pet Sementry. Just read the Bachman books and 'The Long Walk' is worth the price of the book alone.

Expand full comment
Kailani B.'s avatar

The Long Walk sounds interesting. I’ll add it to my list.

Expand full comment
Jason Duck's avatar

Yeah it's vicious. A sick observation satire about fame and fortune and how people will do anything for it.

Expand full comment
Dave Turner's avatar

Weirdly, the only King book I've failed to finish is Pet Sematary. It's incredibly dark (I think he said he thinks of it as his darkest) and I made the schoolboy error of reading it in hospital while recovering from multiple cardiac arrests. So it might just be a me problem...

Expand full comment
Kailani B.'s avatar

So…I shouldn’t read it at night just before I go to bed?

Expand full comment
Dave Turner's avatar

Especially if you have a cat.

Expand full comment
Kailani B.'s avatar

No cats. Just chickens.

Expand full comment
Dave Turner's avatar

You should be ok then. I don’t remember any zombie chickens (I can’t be certain no zombie chickens turn up past the bit I stopped reading though)

Expand full comment
Jason Duck's avatar

Could have been worse you could have been reading a Robin Cooke book.

Expand full comment
R.E. Holding's avatar

Some things exist in our lives for a season, and that includes works by particular people. I think it's good to expand into new territories and find new authors to love and hate 😄

Expand full comment
Kailani B.'s avatar

And I’m loving going to other authors.

Expand full comment